• Amaury Marti Watch

    Amaury Marti is currently hitting .424/.509/.633 in 39 games for the Mexican Red Devils of the Mexican League, also known as Liga de Amaury Cazana. Bud Selig ordered the Cardinals to banish him to there, in fear of the major leagues losing competitive balance.

    Amaury also refuses to accept the watch curse. He has the power to curse, and the power to bless.

  •  

    November 2007
    M T W T F S S
    « Oct   Dec »
     1234
    567891011
    12131415161718
    19202122232425
    2627282930  
  • RSS FirstInning.com: St. Louis Cardinals Daily Report

  • My del.icio.us

  • Flickr Photos

    lynn

    Shane peterson

    Louisville_Zack_Pitts_

    brettwallaceswing

    Jason Buursma

    More Photos
  • Visitors

    • 1,427,779 hits
  • Header design

  • Google Reader or Homepage
    Add to My Yahoo!
    Subscribe with Bloglines
    Subscribe in NewsGator Online

    Add to My AOL
    Add to Technorati Favorites!

erik’s Top 25 (6-10)

Moving on up, we’re getting to the bacon of Cardinal prospectdom, which as AZ noted earlier today leans heavy on pitchers.

10. Mitch Boggs. No one seems to be all that high on Boggs,  other then the Cardinal brass, who have continually sung his praises, one scout going so far as to say he’s the best starting pitcher in the system. I guess he’s overlooked because he doesn’t really blow you away, but Boggs makes all his starts, eats innings, and keeps his team in the game. ZiPS thinks he has the goods to be the team’s fifth starter right now.

9. Kenny Maiques. Now we’re moving into the good stuff. I’ve seen Maiques several times and I think His stuff is as good as anyone in the system, with a 94 MPH fastball and a very, very good slider. There’s talk of him moving him into starting, and I think his stuff can translate there as well. He is a bit small, and he told me he looks up to Roy Oswalt, another short man with great stuff. I’m not sure if he will be that good, we can daydream. But really, his stuff is darn good. Did I mention I like his stuff?

8. Pete Kozma. I am not as down on Kozma as AZ, but I do worry about the same things. I’m putting him up this high because of his draft status and his early returns weren’t too shabby, either. It’s pretty divided when it comes to opinions regarding Kozma. BA says he was the best overall SS of the draft, while others like Gomez and Law think he’s going to be middling. The Cardinals liked his swing enough to take him as early as they did, so I’ll trust their judgment for now.

7. Clayton Mortensen. I really like Mortensen and I hope I’m not overly enamored with his early returns. It’s the K + groundball rates that have me all worked up, and his control was very nice as well. Couple that in with some glowing reviews from BA, and a great performance in the instructional league and I see a lot to like. I think he’ll at least finish his next season in AA, and could work his way into the big league rotation mid 2009. BA says they saw him near the front of the rotation, which is more then what they could say for Ottavino and Herron. I’m going out on a limb here, and will boldly predict by the end of the year he will be in the top 3 of all the Cardinal prospects, and in the Top 100 prospects in the minors. For now, I’ll exercise some constraint and put him here at # 7.

6. Tyler Herron. Love the command, control, dominance and groundball rates, and the fact that he is a young kid not far removed from high school. He’s in his third year of fulltime pitching, and the third time around he’s really come into his own. His peripheral stats aren’t far removed from Jaime Garcia’s last year, though he doesn’t have Garcia’s curveball or sinker. But both of those pitches of his are quite good in their own right. I wish the Cardinals would take more chances on players like him in the draft.

11 Responses to “erik’s Top 25 (6-10)”

  1. Eric - I saw at VEB you listed guys who you thought would make it but didn’t list Ma1ques or even Garcia. What criteria did you use? PAss Rookie status? Have a year above replacement value?

  2. i can always count on you guys to catch my slips. (and that is a good thing) i didn’t use any criteria, just totally spaced. totally spaced. not sure how else i can explain it, just wasn’t thinking.

  3. well, i was pretty sure Garcia was just an oversight but thought there might be the off chance that you were really down on him because of the elbow.

  4. nope, you’ll see tomorrow how much i still like him.

  5. Speaking of spacing, shouldn’t Arnoldi Cruz show up on the “system at a glance”? I thought he was considered a sleeper.

  6. i can’t really make an accurate read on arnoldi yet, but i suppose i could include him. it just seems early, but i guess he could get the sample size flag.

  7. I also REALLY like Maiques. I am extremely torn on whether or not the Cards should move him to a starter or not. I really think he could be the kind of guy that could surprise a lot of people and move up quickly through the system. I actually like him more than I do Ottavino. The only question left in my mind is can he develop an effective 3rd pitch that would help in move into a starting role. If he is unable to turn into a starter my worst case scenerio to me would still be as an 8th inning setup guy.

  8. Erik - Looking at your spreadsheet on who’s in the system - how come no “love” for Nick Webber?

  9. I probably should put him on there, but I don’t think much of him. His sinker I hear is grade A, but his k/bb ratio is atrocious, and that doesn’t portend great things for him. he’s also been very hittable. i think he could stick as a middle reliever, but my gut read is he’s a guy who has a very short MLB career, if any. Hopefully he can improve and prove me wrong.

  10. Off topic, just wanted to say you’ve got one heck of a blog here Erik. Looks awesome.

  11. “If you sprinkle bits of bacon on bacon, I bet you can travel back in time.” Can we try that with the Mulder-Haren trade?

Leave a Reply